Rating:***
Lucky are we, the famished cineastes, to get two films that merit
more than a passing glance within one week - Rajat Kapoor's "Mithya"
and Rohit Jugraj's "Superstar".
Alas, no luck for the poor and damned Bollywood struggler VK (Ranvir
Shorey) in Kapoor's mellow, modern, mythic and mildly majestic "Mithya".
Ranvir, who specialises in playing urban losers, plays the kind
of Kafkaesque hero whose shoes you'd never like to be in. Unless
you're a sucker for misery, pain and doom.
Director Rajat Kapoor pieces together a melancholic, deeply metaphorical
and yet straightforward tale of moral redemption.
"Mithya" plants its two feet in the outwardly incompatible
worlds of Bollywood and the underworld. These come together in "Mithya"
in an unexpected synthesis of lyricism and brutality.
At heart, "Mithya" is an intriguing love story situated
in the heart of darkness where light penetrates through the simplicity
and goodness that we believe exists at the heart of mankind. Goodness
lives at the end though the well-meaning protagonist doesn't survive.
The humanism that underlines the bristling barbarism of the cult
of gangsterism is what supplants Kapoor's narrative with an enchanting
integrity.
Not all of the material that goes into telling the junior artiste's
journey from struggle to power to annihilation is equally meritorious.
Some portions of the narrative, for instance the longish boat ride
from Mumbai to Goa when Ranvir is taken captive by the gangsters,
loses its grip and gives us a chance to lose our attention.
The other spell of inclement weather in the capricious plot occurs
when Ranvir kidnaps his look-alike's kids and spends quality time
with them at the good-hearted moll's aunt's place.
Really, the baggy portions are much too self-indulgent to belong
in a film that breaks the mould so freely and feelingly. The director
quickly cottons on to the captivating tragedy that underlines the
struggler's strange and madding adventures in gangland.
There's the aging wizened head honcho (Naseeruddin Shah) and his
smouldering moll (Neha Dhupia) who play a vital part in Ranvir's
journey from anonymity to doom. These characters are almost cartoonish
in their telltale characterisations.
And yet "Mithya" has the audacity and the creative energy,
the sense of wonderment at life's eccentric twists and turns, to
make Ranvir's journey an emblem of life's most lingering lessons
learnt in ways that are terrifying in their finality.
Especially evocative are Ranvir's scenes in his look-alike's home
where the dead gangster's mother (Suhasini Mulay), wife (Irawati
Harshe) and two kids suddenly come into unexpected attention and
affection from the father of the family.
The plot weaves in and out of these dislocated lives, not quite
knitting the perfect pastiche of pain passion and perversity that
we expected, but getting close to its intentions.
"Mithya" is one of those remarkable films that are driven
more passionately by intent and purpose than the actual rendering
of the creator's vision.
As in "Superstar", where Kunal Khemu's double role invested
the plot with intimate energy, in "Mithya" Ranvir carries
the show with brilliance. His interpretation of a common man's uncommon
adventures is so endearingly befuddled and motivated by an intuitive
comprehension of the loser's language that you're left looking at
an actor who completes assumes and owns his character's world.
The sequence where the producer Tinu Anand is dumbfounded by the
ganglord (actually the struggling actor) turning a business meeting
into an impromptu audition, is a splendid example of how far this
film stretches the theme of illusion and reality without snapping
the link between the two.
Ranvir gets outstanding support from the supporting cast. Neha
and Irawati are portraits of sensuality and femininity done in colours
that enrich the frames through understatement.
But did Dhupia have to be so obviously dressed for her moll's part
in a film where the clothes do not define the characters and their
psychological design?
Another worthwhile performance comes from Harsh Chhaya as the murdered
gangster's brother. Watch him in the scene where he's baffled by
the replacement-look-alike's enthusiasm at the gangster's kids'
parents-teacher meeting.
And the always-watchable Vinay Pathak sportingly pitches in a supporting
performance as a henchman
"Mithya" is a mellowed-down account of a fierce gangland
rivalry. But none of the actors are seen fighting for a voice or
a space. In a world gone awry and propelled by moral tensions, the
characters fit in without pressure.