Rating:***
For too long now Bollywood has used foreign locales as exotic interlude
of backgrounds for songs. In more recent times Indian films, even
if helmed by NRI's, have strived to be more authentic in their depiction
of the rootless existence and a strong desire to connect with India
of those who have chosen to live abroad.
Tanuja Chandra's "Hope and a Little Sugar" goes further
by showing us how a tragedy in your adopted country can hit you
where it hurts most. The way it turns your life upside down, with
grief disconnecting you from your loved ones, the hate it builds
up and in the end how with a little hope, allows you to forgive
and let go.
"Hope and a Little Sugar" manages to be much more than
just a movie about Indians living abroad. It is about how tragedy
forces each one to find his own way to overcome. This is a mature
film and a sign that Chandra is ready to handle grand themes and
to depict that grandness through the details of people's lives.
She stays away from the stereotypes that could have so easily plagued
this movie. Another wise choice is the toning down of the melodrama.
A story about a colonel dealing with the death of his son in the
Sept 11, 2001 attacks is a trap for melodrama and sentiment to ram
us with. Instead, Chandra trusts her story and her actors to carry
the movie. The few emotional scenes work simply because Chandra
allows the unspeakable raging emotions to build up to be released
only at the right time for proper dramatic effect.
The film is set in New York with the Oberoi family living a happy
life till the Sept 11 attacks claims their son Harry (Vikram Chatwal).
The son's wife Saloni (Mahima Chaudhary) befriends a young man Ali
(Amit Sial) at first in a case of mistaken identity. He becomes
close to the family. All changes when Saloni's husband is killed
in the 9/11 attack. The rest of the movie focuses on each characters
struggle to cope with this loss.
The strongest point of this movie is Anupam Kher. He sinks his
teeth into a complex role and manages to evoke empathy as a man
struggling to cope with the loss of his son, his tenacious effort
to find him even after everyone close to him has given up, be consumed
with misplaced hatred and eventually after a horrific incident,
come to be the point of forgiveness.
Mahima is ravishing and anchors her performance by not making her
character, who is free spirited, into something of a bimbo.
Chandra must be commended for taking a tragedy and not exploiting
it for sentiment or using it to dress some mindless fare in serious
garb. The tragedy doesn't just cast a shadow on the lives, it creeps
into the soul and makes the characters question their reasons for
existence.
She also deftly handles the way Indians abroad choose to surround
themselves with trinkets and other items that remind them of their
true home. On Saloni's bedroom wall is displayed a shawl that looks
like it was made in Nagaland or Northeast India.
It is these objects and pieces, family, friends and sometimes hope
that we all need to face even the most insurmountable challenges
that hatred and ignorance will almost surely thrown our way. For
striving to be honest and respecting our intelligence, "Hope
and a Little Sugar" is worth watching.